Russian military expenditure: What's behind the curtain?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15355/2.1.51Abstract
The article views the Russian defense budget as a representation of national strategic interests, priorities, and policies. Although Russia conforms to the United Nations' statistical standard for reporting military expenditure, several budget categories are hidden in other parts of the federal budget. Transparency in defense spending has been decreasing steadily. The budgeting process itself is cumbersome and opaque. Parliamentary control over the budget process and control over the execution of defense appropriations are limited. Importantly, frequent changes in the system of national accounting impede historical comparisons. The study finds that the low quality of defense management, dominated by members of the military-industrial complex, is a major problem locking Russian defense policy in an institutional trap.References
Baluevskiy, Yu. 2005. “ Tseli i sredstva” [Goals and means]. Rossiyskaya gazeta, No. 13. 26 January 2005, p. 7.
Betz, D.J. 2002. “No Place for a Civilian? Russian Defense Management from Yeltsin to Putin.” Armed Forces and Society, Vol. 28, No. 3, pp. 481-504.
Brauer, J. 2004. “United States Military Expenditure.” Public lecture at The Other Economic Summit (TOES) conference in conjunction with the G8 meeting, Brunswick, GA, 8-10 June 2004.
Brzoska, M. 1995. “World Military Expenditures,” pp. 45-67 in K. Hartley and T. Sandler, eds. Handbook of Defense Economics, vol. 1. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Budget Code. 1998. Byudzhetnyi kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsyi No 145-FZ ot 31.07.1998 [Budget Code of Russian Federation # 145-FZ from 31.07.1998]. ConsultantPlus® database software.
Burenok, V. 2004. “Nauchno-metodicheskie osobennosti razrabotki gosudarstvennoy programmy vooruzheniya” [Scientific and methodological features of the state armament program development]. Voennaya mysl, No. 4, pp. 2-8.
CEPAL. 2005. “Methodology for the Comparison of Military Expenditures.” Santiago, Chile: Nationes Unidas, CEPAL.
Chernyak, I. and Yu Gavrilov. 2005. “Yuri Baluevskiy: s NATO voevat’ ne sobiraemsya [Yuri Baluevskiy: We are not going fight against NATO]. Rossiyskaya gazeta. No. 245. 1 November 2005, pp. 1, 10.
Cooper, J. 2006. “Military Expenditure in the 2005 and 2006 Federal Budgets of the Russian Federation.” Research note prepared as background to the SIPRI Yearbook chapter on military expenditure, January.
Crane, K., R. Cliff, E. Medeiros, J. Mulvenon, and W. Overholt. 2005. Modernizing China’s Military: Opportunities and Constraints. RAND monograph MG-260. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
Diamond, J. 2002. “The New Russian Budget System: A Critical Assessment and Future Reform Agenda.” OECD Journal on Budgeting, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 119-147.
Federal Law. 1996. Federal’nyi zakon No. 61-FZ ot 31.05.1996 “Ob oborone” [Federal Law # 61-FZ from 31.05.1996 “About Defense”]. ConsultantPlus®database software.
Federal Law. 2005. Federal’nyi zakon No. 189-FZ ot 26.12.2005 “O federal’nom byudzhete na 2006 god” [Federal Law # 189-FZ from 26.12.2005 “About federal budget for 2006”]. ConsultantPlus® database software.
Fedorov, Y.F. 2002. “Democratic Transformation of the Security Sector in Russia: A Sad Saga of Failure.”Working Paper Series No. 98. Geneva: Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces.
Fontanel, J. 2003. “Les dépenses militaries de la Russie au début du XXIe siècle.” Annuaire français de relations internationales, Vol. 4, pp. 568-583.
Harrison, M. 2003. “How Much Did the Soviets Really Spend on Defense? New Evidence From the Close of the Brezhnev Era.” PERSA Working Paper No. 24 (Version 3 January 2003). University of Warwick, Department of Economics.
IMF. 2002. Government Finance Statistics Manual 2001. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.
Ivanov, S. 2005. “Vystuplenie Ministra oborony RF S.B. Ivanova na soveshchanii rukovodyashchego sostava Vooruzhennykh Sil Rossiyskoy Federatsii” (Moskwa, 9 noyabrya 2005 goda) [Statement of RF Minister of Defense S.B. Ivanov at a meeting with the leading personnel of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, Moscow, 9 November, 2005]. Krasnaya zvezda, No. 208. 11 November 2005, p. 3.
Kosiak, S. 2006. “Classified Funding in the FY 2007 Defense Budget Request.” Washington, DC: Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments.
Kudelina, L. 2006. “Oboronnyi byudzhet 2006: prioritety i osobennosti” [Defense budget 2006: priorities and features]. Rossiyskoye voennoye obozrenie, No. 1, pp. 16-20.
Kvashnin, A. 2001. “Perspektivnaya sistema planirovaniya stroitelstva Vooruzhonnykh Sil” [A prospective planning system for Armed Forces structure development]. Voennaya mysl, No. 6, pp. 2-7.
Law. 1993. Zakon ot 21 Iyulya 1993 g. No. 5485-1 “O gosudarstvennoy taine” [Law of 21 July 1993 No. 5485-1 “On State Secrets”]. ConsultantPlus® database software.
McCaffery, J.L. and L.R. Jones. 2004. Budgeting and Financial Management for National Defense. Greenwich: Information Age Publishing.
Matveev, A. 2006. “Oboronnyi byudzhet etogo goda mozhno nazvat’ komfortnym” [Defense budget of this year can be called comfortable]. Voenno-promyshlennyi kurier. No. 14, p. 7.
Mikhailov, S. 2006. “Plyusy i minusy oboronnogo byudzheta” [Advantages and shortcomings of defense budgets]. Voenno-promyshlennyi kurier, No. 36, p. 1.
MOD. 2006. Prikaz Ministra oborony RF ot 30 iyunya 2006 g. No. 200 “Poryadok obespecheniya denezhnym dovolstviem voennosluzhashchikh Vooruzhennykh Sil Rossiyskoy Federatsii” [Ministry of Defense Order No. 200 of 30 June 2006 “Procedure for provision with money allowance military servants of ArmedForces of Russian Federation”]. ConsultantPlus® database software.
Ovsienko, Yu. V. 2005. “The Institutional Barriers to the Modernization of Russia.” Economika i Matematicheskie Metody., Vol. 41, No. 2, pp.44-55 [in Russian].
Pulin, G. 2006. “Novyi format voenno-promyshlennoy komissii” [New format of the military-industrial committee]. Voenno-promyshlennyi kurier, No. 12, p. 6.
Putin, V. 2004. “Poslanie Federal’nomy Sobraniyu Rossiyskoy Federatsii” [Annual Address to the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation]. Kremlin, Moscow. 26 May 2004.
Regulation. 2006a. Postanovlenie Pravitel’stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 22 fevralya 2006 g. No. 101 “O merakh po realizatsii federalnigo zakona “O federal’nom byudzhete na 2006 god” [Governmental regulation of Russian Federation of 22 February 2006 No. 101 “About federal budget for 2006”]. ConsultantPlus® database software.
Regulation. 2006b. Postanovlenie Pravitel’stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii ot 18 sentyabrya 2006 g. No. 573 “O predostavlenii sotsial’nykh garantiy grazhdanam, dopushchenym k gosudarstvennoy taine na postoyannoy osnove i sotrudnikam structurnykh podrazdeleniy po zashchite gosudarstvennoy tayny” [Governmental regulation of Russian Federation of 18 September 2006 No. 573 “About accordance of social guarantees to citizens admitted to state secrets on constant basis and to servants of secret guarding organization departments”]. ConsultantPlus® database software.
Rosefielde, S. 2005. Russia in the 21st Century: The Prodigal Superpower. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Rosstat. 2005. Natsyonal’nye scheta Rossii v 1997-2004 godakh: Stat. Sb. [National Accounts of Russia in 1997-2004: Stat. Compendium]. Moscow: Rosstat.
Rosstat. 2006. Rossiyskiy statisticheskiy ezhegodnik. 2005 [Russian Statistical Yearbook 2005]. Moscow: Rosstat.
Stiglitz, J.E. 2000. Economics of the Public Sector. New York: W.W. Norton.
United Nations. 2002. Transparency in Armaments. United Nations Standardized Instrument for Reporting Military Expenditures: Guidelines. New York: United Nations Department for Disarmament Affairs.
United Nations. 2005. Objective Information on Military Matters, including Transparency of Military Expenditures: Report of the Secretary-General. A/60/159. New York: United Nations.
United Nations. 2006. Objective Information on Military Matters, including Transparency of Military Expenditures: Report of the Secretary-General. A/61/133. New York: United Nations.
Vasilchuk, E. 2006. “Punktom pervym povestki dnya” [As first in agenda]. Rossiyskaya biznes-gazeta, No. 15, p. 7.
WMEAT. 2002. World Military Expenditures and Arms Transfers 1999-2000. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of State. Bureau of Verification and Compliance.
